What types of cakes does A Piece of Cake specialize in?

A Piece of Cake specializes in custom cakes for various occasions, including weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, and other special events. They are adept at creating a range of styles from classic to modern designs.

Does A Piece of Cake accommodate dietary restrictions?

Specific dietary options are not detailed in our available information. We highly recommend contacting A Piece of Cake directly to discuss any specific dietary needs or allergen concerns you may have for your custom order.

What is the typical lead time for a wedding cake order?

For custom wedding cakes, it is generally advised to book at least 3-6 months in advance, especially during peak wedding seasons, to ensure availability and ample time for design and preparation.

How can I get a price quote for a custom cake?

To receive a personalized quote for your custom cake, please contact A Piece of Cake directly via phone or their website to schedule a consultation. Pricing varies based on size, design complexity, and flavors.

A Piece of Cake

484 N Madison Ave, Greenwood, IN 46142, USA

ClassicTraditionalModernCustom

About

A Piece of Cake is a cherished local bakery serving the Indianapolis area from its Greenwood, IN location. With a strong presence and 173 reviews, this establishment has built a reputation for crafting beautiful and delicious custom cakes. They are known for bringing clients' visions to life, making them a popular choice for special occasions throughout Central Indiana. Their dedication to personalized service and quality confections makes them a go-to for those seeking a unique centerpiece for their celebrations.

Profile last updated: May 12, 2026

Pricing & Booking

Pricing for custom cakes at A Piece of Cake is determined by design complexity, size, and flavor choices. Please contact them directly for a personalized quote.

We recommend scheduling a consultation to discuss your custom cake needs. A deposit is typically required to secure your booking.

Specialties

ClassicTraditionalModern

Similar Bakers in Indianapolis

Cake Types

weddingbirthdayanniversarycustom

Dietary Options

standard

The Story of A Piece of Cake

A Piece of Cake has been a beloved fixture in the Indianapolis and Greenwood, IN, baking scene, establishing itself as a go-to for custom confections. While the exact origin story isn't detailed, the bakery's consistent popularity, evidenced by numerous positive reviews, speaks to its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Their philosophy centers on creating personalized cakes that are not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious, ensuring each celebration is made sweeter. The bakery's signature style revolves around custom design, adapting to a wide range of aesthetic preferences, from timeless elegance to contemporary flair. Clients consistently praise A Piece of Cake for their attentive service, ability to translate unique ideas into edible art, and the exceptional taste of their cakes. Many reviews highlight the bakery's reliability and the joy their creations bring to significant life events.

Why Choose A Piece of Cake?

Choose A Piece of Cake for a well-established local bakery experience known for personalized service and custom cake designs. Their strong reputation in the Indianapolis area highlights their ability to create memorable and delicious centerpieces for any celebration.

Frequently Asked Questions

Customer Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to leave a review!

Leave a Review

Quick Info

$$ Mid-Range · $300–$600

Pricing for custom cakes at A Piece of Cake is determined by design complexity, size, and flavor choices. Please contact them directly for a personalized quote.

Prices vary by design, size & season

LocationIndianapolis, IN

Service Area50 miles

Reviews173

Lead Time13+ weeks

Experience0+ years

Wedding Cake Pricing by Season

Seasonal demand trends for Indianapolis, IN based on wedding industry data

JFMAMJJASOND

Book in January for up to 20% savings on wedding cake pricing.

June and October are peak months — book early for best availability.

PeakShoulderLow Season

Delivery Check

Delivers within 50 miles of Indianapolis, IN

Your venue address or zip code

Cake Planning Timeline

12-18 monthsStart researching cake bakers and styles

9-12 monthsBook tastings with your top 3 bakers

6-9 monthsConfirm your baker and place deposit

1-2 monthsFinalize design, flavors, and delivery details

Read the full planning guide →