What types of events do you bake for?

Sarah's Cake Shop creates custom cakes for a wide range of events, including weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, baby showers, corporate events, and other special celebrations. They also offer cupcakes, cookies, and various sweet treats.

How far in advance should I order my wedding cake?

For wedding cakes, it is highly recommended to book 6 to 9 months in advance, especially during peak wedding seasons, to ensure availability. For other custom cakes, lead times can vary, so it's best to inquire as early as possible.

What is the process for ordering a custom wedding cake?

The process typically begins with a tasting and design consultation by appointment. During this meeting, you'll discuss your vision, flavors, and design elements. A custom quote will be provided, and a deposit secures your date and details.

What is your signature cake style?

While Sarah's Cake Shop excels in custom designs ranging from classic elegance to modern chic, they are particularly known for intricate detailing, beautiful floral work (including delicate gumpaste flowers), and flawless finishes that make each cake a unique masterpiece tailored to their clients.

Sarah's Cake Shop

10 Clarkson Wilson Center, Chesterfield, MO 63017, USA

$$$

Request Quote

Own Sarah's Cake Shop? Claim this free listing

ElegantClassicModernFloralWhimsicalTiered+1 more

woman ownedBooks 6 months out

What we know about Sarah's Cake Shop

Choose Sarah's Cake Shop for a truly bespoke wedding cake experience, combining stunning artistry with delectable flavors. Their personalized design process and commitment to exquisite detail ensure your cake is a unique and memorable centerpiece, crafted by an experienced team dedicated to perfection.

Location: St. Louis, MO
Starting price: $500
Book by: 26 weeks ahead
Styles: Elegant, Classic, Modern

What we know

🌱 Caters vegan, gluten-free

What we don't

📅 Wants 6 months' notice

About

Sarah's Cake Shop, nestled in Chesterfield, MO, is a premier destination for custom wedding cakes and celebratory confections, proudly serving the greater St. Louis metropolitan area since 2008. Renowned for their exquisite artistry and delectable flavors, they specialize in bringing couples' unique visions to life, ensuring every cake is a memorable centerpiece for their special day. From elegant multi-tiered designs adorned with intricate gumpaste flowers to whimsical creations, Sarah's Cake Shop is dedicated to personalized service, crafting edible masterpieces for all significant life events. With a strong focus on quality ingredients and meticulous attention to detail, the team at Sarah's Cake Shop ensures every creation not only looks stunning but tastes incredible. Their commitment to delivering bespoke designs and exceptional taste has made them a beloved choice for those seeking a truly unique and delicious custom cake experience in the St. Louis region, leaving a lasting impression on every guest.

Profile last updated: October 18, 2026

Pricing & Booking

Pricing for custom wedding cakes varies significantly based on design complexity, size, and chosen flavors. Consultations are required to receive a personalized quote, reflecting the bespoke nature of their artistry.

Requires a tasting and design consultation by appointment for wedding cakes. A non-refundable deposit is typically required to secure the date and order. Specific details on payment schedules and cancellation policies are discussed during the consultation.

Specialties

ElegantClassicModernFloralWhimsicalTieredCustom-designed

Cake Types

WeddingBirthdayAnniversaryCustomCorporate

Dietary Options

Vegan

Reviews from couples on WeddingCakes Hub

No reviews yet. Be the first to leave a review!

Leave a Review

Allergen Safety

Sarah's Cake Shop can accommodate gluten-free and vegan requests. However, it is important to note that they are not a dedicated gluten-free or vegan facility, and cross-contamination with common allergens like wheat, dairy, and nuts is possible. Clients with severe allergies should discuss their specific needs thoroughly during consultation.

The Story of Sarah's Cake Shop

Sarah's Cake Shop began its journey in St. Louis in 2008, founded by Sarah, whose lifelong passion for baking and artistry blossomed into a beloved local business. From its inception, the shop has been driven by a philosophy of combining high-quality ingredients with meticulous design, transforming client visions into breathtaking edible art. This dedication has established Sarah's Cake Shop as a go-to for bespoke wedding and celebration cakes in the Chesterfield and wider St. Louis metropolitan area. The team at Sarah's Cake Shop prides itself on creating not just cakes, but memorable experiences. Clients consistently commend them for their unparalleled attention to detail, delicious flavors, and seamless execution. They appreciate the collaborative process, from initial design consultations to the flawless delivery of their perfect cake. The commitment to personalized service ensures that each creation truly reflects the individual style and taste of the couple, making every occasion extra special.

Frequently Asked Questions

General planning guidance

Wedding Cake Pricing by Season

The general wedding-season demand curve — a guide to when cakes cost more, not St. Louis, MO pricing or any one baker's rates.

JFMAMJJASOND

Book in January for up to 20% savings on wedding cake pricing.

June and October are peak months — book early for best availability.

PeakShoulderLow Season

Delivery Check

Delivers within 50 miles of St. Louis, MO

Your venue address or zip code

Is this your business?

Claim Sarah's Cake Shop to edit your profile, add photos, and receive quote requests from couples directly. It's free and takes about two minutes.

Claim this listing

Cake Planning Timeline

12-18 monthsStart researching cake bakers and styles

9-12 monthsBook tastings with your top 3 bakers

6-9 monthsConfirm your baker and place deposit

1-2 monthsFinalize design, flavors, and delivery details

Read the full planning guide →