What we know about Taylor's Bakery
Choose Taylor's Bakery for a wedding cake crafted with over a century of experience, combining timeless elegance with personalized design. Their renowned reputation in Indianapolis ensures a delicious and beautifully memorable centerpiece for your special day.
Profile last updated: October 18, 2026
Custom wedding cakes typically start from $400 for smaller tiered designs. Final pricing varies based on cake size, design intricacy, and chosen flavors, with detailed quotes provided after a consultation.
Requires a consultation and tasting appointment, typically followed by a deposit to secure your wedding date. Early booking is highly recommended due to high demand, especially during peak wedding seasons.
No reviews yet. Be the first to leave a review!
Taylor's Bakery offers gluten-free and nut-free options and takes care to address allergen concerns. However, as a traditional bakery handling various ingredients, cross-contamination is possible. Couples with severe allergies are encouraged to discuss their specific needs during a consultation.
General planning guidance
The general wedding-season demand curve — a guide to when cakes cost more, not Indianapolis, IN pricing or any one baker's rates.
Book in January for up to 20% savings on wedding cake pricing.
June and October are peak months — book early for best availability.
Delivers within 50 miles of Indianapolis, IN
Claim Taylor's Bakery to edit your profile, add photos, and receive quote requests from couples directly. It's free and takes about two minutes.
Claim this listingSponsored
BakeOnyx AI — AI-Powered Cake Design Tools
Turn your cake vision into reality — generate custom designs, get instant pricing estimates, and streamline your baking workflow with AI.
Learn more →