What we know about When Butter met Sugar
When Butter met Sugar stands out in Sheffield for its truly bespoke cake designs, meticulously crafted to reflect each client's unique vision and style. They excel in accommodating diverse dietary needs while delivering exceptional artistry and delicious flavors for every special occasion. Choose them for a personalized, stress-free experience and a memorable centerpiece.
Profile last updated: October 18, 2026
Wedding cakes start from £350. All custom cakes are individually priced based on design complexity, size, number of servings, and flavor choices. A personalized quote is provided after a consultation.
Requires an initial consultation to discuss design and requirements. A bespoke quotation will be provided, and a deposit is required to secure your booking date. Tastings are available by arrangement.
No reviews yet. Be the first to leave a review!
When Butter met Sugar caters to various dietary requirements, including gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, and nut-free options. Clients are advised to discuss specific allergies and intolerances during their consultation. While precautions are taken, cross-contamination cannot be 100% guaranteed in a shared kitchen environment, especially for severe nut allergies.
General planning guidance
The general wedding-season demand curve — a guide to when cakes cost more, not Sheffield, UK pricing or any one baker's rates.
Book in January for up to 20% savings on wedding cake pricing.
June and October are peak months — book early for best availability.
Delivers within 50 miles of Sheffield
Claim When Butter met Sugar to edit your profile, add photos, and receive quote requests from couples directly. It's free and takes about two minutes.
Claim this listingSponsored
Voxeli — Every Book, Out Loud
Turn any PDF, EPUB or TXT into a narrated audiobook, or pick from 70,000+ free classics. Free on iOS and Android.
Learn more →